So after seeing Spidey-3, I thought I’d list the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of comic ok based movies (big screen only). These are, of course, just my opinion, you may differ, if so please share. They are listed in alphabetical order not preferencitial order, and I’m sure there are some that I’ve missed.
The Good
- Batman
- Batman Returns
- Blade
- Blade 2
- Constantine
- Hellboy
- Hulk (see Bad)
- Spider-man 1
- X-Men
The Bad
- Last half hour or so of Hulk
- Superman 1, 2
- Superman Returns
- Spider-man 3
- X-Men 3
- Fantastic Four (saved because of Grimm/Torch)
and The Ugly
- Batman and Robin
- Batman Forever
- Catwoman (ok, never seen it, never will)
- Daredevil
- Elektra
- Superman 3and 4
And finally, the Wow (my best of the best)
- Batman Begins
- Punisher (just sneaks in because its fun)
- Spider-man 2
- X-Men 2
I am Adam "Lurch Kimded" Howie, I kinda run this website, not very well but it is mine... all mine!!! (cue evil laugh) 
Heresy:
Superman 1, 2
I liked them:
Superman Returns
Unfortunatlly correct:
X-Men 3
Heresy:
Blade 1 and 2. Ugh.
Also agree with Andy on Superman 1 and 2…they’re good films. Especially wth the effects they managed to do at the time.
I liked Blade, although to be honest I should have added an “Ok” column to sit between “good” and “bad”, which if I did would change the “good” and “bad” columns quite a bit.